What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives concerning the war in Ukraine?
This question has piqued widespread curiosity following several recent rounds of ceasefire talks, which until now seemed to yield little progress four years since the full-scale military offensive.
Another round of American-facilitated negotiations is expected to occur in Geneva later this week. In preparation, an important participant of the Ukrainian leadership's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in recent military-to-military talks, has provided his viewpoint.
According to Kyslytsya, these interactions are professional and generally free of the sort of political and rhetorical grandstanding observed elsewhere by Moscow.
"The military have a better grasp of what is going on in the combat zone," he remarked in a conversation earlier this week.
"The question remains whether they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of reporting [back] accurately…free from altering or distorting the information," he added.
It is far from an simple thing to attempt to end a war. The reality of the battlefield in the Donbas region - where tens of thousands of drones patrol and strike over a huge so-called "grey zone" between the two sides, while two hundred thousand Ukrainian residents still live in the "heavily fortified" cities of the eastern region - makes the practical process of separation extremely complicated.
"It is essential to establish a clear framework of rules and protocols," the diplomat explained, "along with a way to verify and oversee."
The Role of External Mediators
A great deal of these preparations, he said, is complete, thanks in part to the direct participation of American officials, including General Alexus Grynkewich and Dan Driscoll.
It's obviously not in Ukraine's benefit to disparage envoys of the current US administration, but when Kyslytsya compliments the US delegation for its work, he sounds genuine.
"We have to credit the US side for their commitment and their perseverance," he states, "since they attend the sessions non-stop. They not only observe…they put inquiries and they listen to our answers."
The negotiator was equally positive about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he referred to as "experienced", and billionaire envoy Steve Witkoff, whom he described as "far more astute person than the simplified portrayal you see in the media".
The US, he asserted, will play a critical function in overseeing any potential truce, with resources encompassing satellite and other types of high-tech surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will serve as an arbitrator, because if there is a violation there must be a neutral actor that is reliable [and] authoritative."
Previous and Present Monitoring Realities
For eight years prior to Russia's major offensive in 2022, this oversight function was played by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe - a body whose restricted means and lack of punitive powers rendered it largely incapable of preventing an intensification.
"It was no small feat [for them] just to have a couple of drones airborne above the area," Kyslytsya said. "It's kind of the stone age period in contrast with what we have today."
By contrast, recent reports suggest that as many as 12,000 drones are active over the single city of Pokrovsk at any one time.
An Insider's Perspective on Confronting the Opposition
When asked how he managed to negotiate directly from delegates from a leader in the Russian government who has shown readiness to expend more than a million of his country's soldiers to conquer Ukraine, Kyslytsya, also a former UN ambassador, provided his answer.
He told that he'd had a long time of practice.
"I witnessed far more difficult situations. I served a five-year term in at the UN, three of them before the full-scale invasion. I regularly had to sit in the room with the adversary on a regular basis."
One evening is seared in his recollection: 23 February 2022.
In the middle of an emergency Security Council session, called to discuss the urgent crisis in Ukraine, the ambassador received news that his country was being assaulted.
Simultaneously, seven time zones to the east in Kyiv, the first far-off explosions were heard as Russia's total attack on Ukraine began.
During moments of intense tension, the ambassador attempted to persuade his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to call his boss, the Russian foreign minister, to obtain assurances that Russian troops would not cross the border.
"I have stated everything that I am aware of today," Nebenzia responded, as recalled by his Ukrainian colleague. "I will not wake the minister at this time."
Everyone's lives changed at that instant. The diplomat remained at the United Nations for an additional period before going back to Kyiv.
The Road Ahead
If the delegations meet again in Switzerland on Thursday, he'll be there, still thrashing out the details and logistics of a ceasefire but anticipating continuously for the most important part of the jigsaw to be resolved.
"Hostilities could be stopped by simply one call of an individual to his top general," he said.
"But apparently, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not up to ending the conflict at present."